This Anglican church is the third All Saints to stand on this site. This Anglican church was completed in 1914, dedicated May of that year and consecrated 29 October 1916. The first vicar of the new church was the Reverend H G Rosher, 1911 – 1915. The first church on the site was built 1875 and was replaced in 1882 by a larger building.

After meetings in 1900 a site for a Congregational church was chosen in Broad Street close to the intersection of Princess Street. The foundation stone for the church was laid in 1900 and the building was in use 1901. The first Minister was Reverend S J Baker. The last service in the building was held in 1957, after a new Church was built at 228 Broadway Avenue. This building was demolished in the 1970s.